Skip to main content
  • Editions
    • International
    • China
    • France
    • India
    • Australia
    • United Kingdom
    • Hong Kong
    • Canada
    • Brazil
    • Germany
    • Russia
  • Magazines
    • Art+Auction

      Modern Painters

  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Photo Galleries
  • Blouin Art Sales Index
  • Gallery Guide
  • Art Sites
  • Boutique
  • Log in

    Not a member?

    Sign up

    Log in

    |Forgot your password?
    OR
    Sign up
  • Sign up
Home
  • Visual Arts
    • Visual Arts Home
    • Contemporary Art
    • Old Masters/Renaissance
    • Impressionism & Modern Art
    • Ancient Arts & Antiques
    • Traditional Arts
    • Museums
    • Reviews
    • Columnists
    • Features
  • Performing Arts
    • Performing Arts Home
    • Film
    • Music
    • Theater & Dance
  • Architecture & Design
    • Architecture & Design Home
    • Design
    • Architecture
  • Artists
  • ART PRICES
  • Market News
    • Market News Home
    • Art Fairs
    • Auctions
    • Collecting
    • Galleries
    • Databank
    • Art & Crime
    • ART PRICES
    • Columnists
  • Style & Society
    • Style Home
    • ART Parties/Scene
    • Fashion
    • Food & Wine
    • Jewelry & Watches
    • Autos & Boats
  • Events
  • Travel
  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Slideshows
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Homepage RSS
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • foursquare
  • tumblr

Search form

International Edition
May 24, 2012 Last Updated: 1:42:AM EDT

Better than Bilbao?

Undefined

Better than Bilbao?

  • Email
  • Print
  • Save
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
Enlarge This Image
by Rachel Somerstein
Published: February 16, 2010

Once a cheerless industrial town known for swathes of blocky apartment buildings, Holon, Israel, seems an unlikely destination for cutting-edge design. But over the past few years, with the opening of the National Israeli Cartoon Museum and the Mediatheque, a youth theater, the city of 200,000 has made efforts to transform itself into a cultural center — now soon to be complete with a new museum designed by Israeli icon Ron Arad. This build-up is taking place at a time when other Israeli arts initiatives are also seeking to take advantage of the country's growing contemporary-art influence and the recent lulling of conflict in the region.

For the Design Museum Holon, Arad told London’s Independent, the town "wanted a building that could feature on a postage stamp.” Arad’s building, slated to open on the 4th of next month, is precisely that. The rust-colored steel structure self-consciously evokes Frank Gehrys Guggenheim in Bilbao, Spain, though, at $17 million, it cost only a fraction of what the Guggenheim did to erect.

The resemblance is no accident. Holon is one of dozens of second-tier cities, from Denver to Dallas, attempting to secure their own slice of the so-called “Bilbao effect.” The formula? Hire a name-brand architect to design an expensive, flashy building, then watch the crowds roll in. For already-established institutions, that pressure can be especially severe; as Maxwell Anderson, director of the Indianapolis Art Museum, recently admitted to the New York Times, the glut of new, outsized institutional architecture is due in part to the “keeping-up-with-the-Joneses quality to museum building.” Too often, though, as architects, critics, and urban planners have pointed out, these statement buildings cause financial hardship, don’t deliver on staggering promises of increased attendance, and fail to properly suit the needs of the institutions they are meant to house.

Perhaps partly as a result, James Snyder, director of Jerusalem’s Israel Museum, cheerfully describes his own institution’s $100 million renovation, slated to open July 26, as “the opposite” of Bilbao. Financially, that’s not entirely true; Bilbao cost the same amount to build. But the Israel Museum secured half its costs before announcing the project. In addition, and in spite of the recession, Snyder also has had success in his campaign to double the museum’s endowment to $150 million, raising $52.1 million thus far. That cushion will likely protect it from economic difficulties that have stemmed from other, similarly expensive institutional expansions — the Daniel Libeskind-designed new wing for the Denver Art Museum comes to mind — and that have delayed and canceled others, at the St. Louis Art Museum, Cincinnati Art Museum, and Buffalo’s Albright-Knox Gallery, among others.

The Israel Museum’s renovation, designed by New York–based James Carpenter and Israel’s Efrat-Kowalsky, reflects a fundamental respect for the 20-acre campus’s original structures, including the iconic Shrine of the Book, home to the Dead Sea Scrolls. Carpenter’s mandate, Snyder explains, “was to develop a signature that would be identifiable as his” while also resonating with the campus’s character. Renderings evoke the bright, airy atmosphere of such previous Carpenter projects as the lobby of 7 World Trade Center and the Time Warner building’s atrium, both in Manhattan. At the same time, the Israel Museum campus as a whole, meant to evoke an Arab village, doesn’t appear radically changed: Its square footage has doubled without enlarging its footprint. Wings devoted to the fine arts, Jewish art and life, and archaeology have also expanded; the space for temporary exhibitions, formerly relegated to the museum’s periphery, has been brought into the center; and the entrance hub and other areas having to do with crowd circulation have been improved.

“This is not the kind of place that you should ever tear down and start again,” says Snyder, a modern art specialist and former MoMA curator who assumed the museum’s directorship in 1996. To inaugurate its new galleries, the museum invited Israeli sculptor Zvi Goldstein and two installation artists — Susan Hiller, an American, and the Nigerian-born Yinka Shonibare — to curate shows of objects drawn from the permanent collection. Goldstein assembled some 600 objects that span human history, ranging from African masks to contemporary works by Donald Judd, and clustered them around poems from his book Room #205; Hiller, by contrast, selected just 35 contemporary pieces by artists from across the world. And Shonibare — who, Snyder points out with obvious pride, had his first mid-career survey at the Israel Museum — chose items relating to the theme of the four elements (earth, wind, fire, and water) around which to create four installations of his own.

The exhibition as a whole mirrors Snyder’s vision, which is “to heighten national awareness of the quality of what we have at home.” Given the recession, Snyder’s mission is not unusual. And local loyalty is especially important in a region where politics drives tourism (or the lack thereof). At the same time, he is committed to independence from the state, and likens the museum’s reliance on regular donors to that of an American nonprofit. (The Israeli government, which kicked in $15 million for the renovation, provides varying amounts of funds each year.) Perhaps partly as a result, Snyder can afford such expenditures as hosting traveling exhibitions of works by William Kentridge, and an exhibition, still some years off, of pieces by minimalist sculptor James Turrell. (Turrell’s Space That Sees is permanently installed at the museum, making it, says Snyder, a meaningful last-stop on the exhibition’s tour).

Discussing his vision, Snyder also highlights the museum’s “unique circumstances,” housing as it does an encyclopedic collection of objects that provide a narrative of both “the history of western material culture” and of the evolution of monotheism. The museum’s location — on a hilltop in one of the world’s most hotly contested cities — is another aspect to that distinctness, which makes museum-building here a more sensitive endeavor than elsewhere in the world. Israel Museum attendance, for example, which Snyder says would have hit 1 million in 2000, diminished to 300,000 in 2001 following the surge in violence of the Second Intifada. (Presently, attendance is about 500,000, says Snyder, an impressive figure given that 90 percent of the museum has been closed since the expansion’s 2007 groundbreaking.) Snyder won't pin down the visitor increase he expects to follow this summer's reopening, but a number of factors suggest it will be greeted with welcome bump: the country’s relative calm; Arad’s Design Museum Holon, which will focus additional attention on the region’s cultural offerings; the ascendance of contemporary Israeli art; the (mostly) positive press stemming from Israel’s humanitarian missions to Haiti; and, of course, the expansion itself. As Snyder himself puts it, “everything is connected.” He adds, “A year from now, we’ll talk.”

Like what you see?

Sign up for our DAILY NEWSLETTER and get our best stories delivered to your inbox.

Go to top ↑
Museums, Museums
Share:
  • Tweet
  • Email to a Friend

Comments

0 Comments
+ Add Yours
Log in or register to post comments
Oldest first Newest first

RELATED ARTICLES

Garage Sale at 11 West 53rd Street! MoMA Curator Sabine Breitwieser on Crowdsourcing Junk for Martha Rosler
The Birth of a Biennial? Carthage Contemporary's Inaugural Exhibition in Tunis Puts the Spotlight on Contemporary Art Post-Revolution
Bon Soir! The 6 Most Exciting Experiences You Can Have During This Weekend's "Night of Museums" in Paris
ARTINFO Ranks the Top 10 Best Museum Web Sites, From the Hirshhorn to the Aspen Art Museum
The Photographers' Gallery Inaugurates Its New Soho Home With Beguiling Edward Burtynsky Exhibition
Edward Burtynsky, Highway #1, Intersection 105 & 110, Los Angeles, California, U

Most Popular

Viral Fashion: How the Facebook Wedding Dress Turned Priscilla Chan Into an Unlikely Style Star
The ARTINFO Bookshelf: 40 Books That Every Artist Should Own, Part II
K8 Hardy Ripped Fashion a New One at Her Riotous Whitney Biennial Runway Show
"When You Interrupt Us, You Have to Deal With Us": Murray Moss Invites You to Intrude at His Midtown Lab
Reagan's Blood, Bieber's Hair, Ally McBeal's PJs: 10 Freakish Items From PFCAuctions's Current Online Sale
The ARTINFO Bookshelf: 40 Books That Every Artist Should Own, Part I
Are We in an Anish Kapoor Bubble? Two Barbara Gladstone Shows Point to the Affirmative

Popular on Social Media

  • "I Don't Like the Term Installation": Daniel Buren on His Grand Palais-Filling Monumenta Show
  • Is Antony Gormley Plotting His Own Foundation in Norfolk?
  • Garage Sale at 11 West 53rd Street! MoMA Curator Sabine Breitwieser on Crowdsourcing Junk for Martha Rosler
  • What If Your Prized Painting Turns Out to Be Nazi Loot? The Niche Market for Art Title Insurance
  • Sale of the Week, May 27-June 2: Christie's Week-Long Hong Kong Auctions Cater to Every Taste
  • Allen Jones, Table (detail), 1969
    Allen Jones's Soft Porn Sculptures Spice Up Sotheby's Gunter Sachs Evening Sale, but Warhol Dominates
  • "When You Interrupt Us, You Have to Deal With Us": Murray Moss Invites You to Intrude at His Midtown Lab
  • K8 Hardy Ripped Fashion a New One at Her Riotous Whitney Biennial Runway Show
  • Viral Fashion: How the Facebook Wedding Dress Turned Priscilla Chan Into an Unlikely Style Star
  • Bonhams Australia Present Six Auctions of Amazing Art and Antiques from May 27 to 29

GO TO:

Home page

Editorial

  • Visual Arts
  • Performing Arts
  • Architecture & Design
  • Artists
  • ART PRICES
  • Market News
  • Style & Society
  • Events
  • Travel
  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Slideshows

Products

  • Magazines
  • Gallery Guide
  • Blouin Art Sales Index
  • Somogy
  • Art Sites
  • Art Jobs

Louise Blouin Media

  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Louise Blouin Foundation
  • RSS
Copyright © 2012 All rights reserved. Use of the site constitutes agreement with our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.