Skip to main content
  • Editions
    • International
    • China
    • France
    • India
    • Australia
    • United Kingdom
    • Hong Kong
    • Canada
    • Brazil
    • Germany
    • Russia
  • Magazines
    • Art+Auction

      Modern Painters

  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Photo Galleries
  • Blouin Art Sales Index
  • Gallery Guide
  • Art Sites
  • Boutique
  • Log in

    Not a member?

    Sign up

    Log in

    |Forgot your password?
    OR
    Sign up
  • Sign up
Home
  • Visual Arts
    • Visual Arts Home
    • Contemporary Art
    • Old Masters/Renaissance
    • Impressionism & Modern Art
    • Ancient Arts & Antiques
    • Traditional Arts
    • Museums
    • Reviews
    • Columnists
    • Features
  • Performing Arts
    • Performing Arts Home
    • Film
    • Music
    • Theater & Dance
  • Architecture & Design
    • Architecture & Design Home
    • Design
    • Architecture
  • Artists
  • ART PRICES
  • Market News
    • Market News Home
    • Art Fairs
    • Auctions
    • Collecting
    • Galleries
    • Databank
    • Art & Crime
    • ART PRICES
    • Columnists
  • Style & Society
    • Style Home
    • ART Parties/Scene
    • Fashion
    • Food & Wine
    • Jewelry & Watches
    • Autos & Boats
  • Events
  • Travel
  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Slideshows
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Homepage RSS
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • foursquare
  • tumblr

Search form

International Edition
May 24, 2012 Last Updated: 5:11:AM EDT

What Makes a Cartoon Character Underage, and Other Issues Raised at an Exhibition of Animated 'Child Pornography'

What Makes a Cartoon Character Underage, and Other Issues Raised at an Exhibition of Animated 'Child Pornography'

Undefined
  • Email
  • Print
  • Save
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
View Slideshow
: 
by Nicolai Hartvig, ARTINFO France
Published: September 2, 2010

The cameras rolled, the newspaper ink flowed. On the eve of the opening of "Udstilling om Animeret Børneporno" ("An Exhibition about Animated Child Porn"), curator Christian Hviid Mortensen received a visit from two plainclothes policemen who, following a public complaint, were there to make video recordings of the show.

Ever since it was first announced by Denmark's Mediemuseum Brandts, the oft-forgotten museum in Odense (the country's third-largest city), the exhibition has caused a storm of controversy. But outrage was quickly diffused on August 20 when the press and the public — both apprehensive and curious, in equal measure — first ventured inside Brandts to see the exhibit.

The works on display through October 24 include a handful of posters, figurines, and controversially erotic Japanese "manga books." Though the books are presented as child porn, few of them depict children and none show underage nudes or sexual acts. Still, they are off-limits to those seeking to flip through their pages, and only the back and front covers of the books are visible through the glass display cases.

"The presence of the words 'child pornography' is a question," Hviid Mortensen told ARTINFO France. "Do you consider this to be child porn? Is it offensive, and is it harmful? We show some of the more lewd types of manga in the 'lolicon' genre, which plays on the 'Lolita' look: the big eyes and pigtails, child-like features placed on well-proportioned, adult bodies. You can't point out a manga cover and say that the girl is nine years old."

Surprisingly, the museum has had only one demonstrator, a man who wrote protest slogans on the door. "I told him the issue was much larger inside his own head than in reality, and invited him to see the exhibit," said Hviid Mortensen. The man declined the invitation, and continued to voice his outrage outside.

Members of the activist group Pornofrit Miljø (Porn-free Environment) also distributed fliers outside the museum, but exhibition staff snagged one of the pamphlets and made it a part of the exhibition.

Hviid Mortensen is happy to see that the show inflames debate. Experts are discussing whether animated child porn increases pedophilia, or if it lessens the harm done to real-life children. Freedom of speech concerns have also been raised, and critics are denouncing the latest fear that indecent images are corrupting moral values. Red Barnet, the Danish child welfare charity, has even approved of the exhibition, however cautiously, so long as it continues to inform and spur dialogue.

Denmark was the first country in the world to legalize pornography, in 1969, and currently it is the only Scandinavian country where animated pornography depicting underage characters is legal. However, the nation's main center-left opposition, Socialdemokraterne in rare concert with the right-wing government coalition party, Dansk Folkeparti — has proposed criminalizing the possession of animated child porn. Among other things, it was this proposal that stirred Hviid Mortensen to assemble the exhibition.

Also inspiring to Hviid Mortensen was the trial of an unidentified Swedish manga translator and researcher who was fined for possessing child pornography. The manga translator had downloaded 51 erotic images that, in the court's judgment, depicted characters "under the age of 18." Consequently, two Swedish media outlets were also reported to the police for possession of the images they used to illustrate their coverage of the trial.

The president of Dansk Tegneserieråd (the Danish Cartoon Council), Thomas Thorhauge, wrote last week in the daily Politiken that this case reflects a Kafka-esque effect of legal uncertainty. Thorhauge went on to question if a family man could be investigated for owning anti-authoritarian cartoons by Robert Crumb, or if a grandmother could get in trouble over her anthology of Carl Larsson — the Swedish painter whose idyllic rural portraits often depict nude children.

In a complicated addition to the proposed criminalization of animated-pornography possession, Danish legislation could specifiy the exemption of images with "artistic value." Of course, this phrasing is confoundedly vague.  "If you have already decided that these cartoons are so terrible, how can they be less terrible just because they qualify as art?" asked Vagn Greve, a law professor at Copenhagen Business School, in the daily paper Information. "Should a good artist have different rights than a bad artist?"

Impassioned debates aside, Hviid Mortensen's exhibition coincided with the opening of Mediamixeren, Brandt's new interactive and highly anticipated space. Despite the occasion being overwhelmed with controversy, the museum welcomed the attention. "We couldn't have asked for better publicity," said Brandts' director,  Ervin Nielsen, at the opening.

Like what you see?

Sign up for our DAILY NEWSLETTER and get our best stories delivered to your inbox.

Go to top ↑
View Slideshow
Art & Crime, Contemporary Arts, Architecture & Design, Galleries, Art & Crime, Postwar & Contemporary Art, Design & Architecture, Galleries
Share:
  • Tweet
  • Email to a Friend

Comments

0 Comments
+ Add Yours
Log in or register to post comments
Oldest first Newest first

RELATED ARTICLES

Friends Rally Behind Japanese Sculptor After His Guerrilla-Art Love Letter to NYC Sparks Bomb Panic
Banksy's Parachuting Rat Destroyed in Australia by a Blundering Builder
Notorious Legal Crusader Sues Czech Republic, Demanding the Return of $50 Million in Nazi-Plundered Art
The Fake Warhols Used as Prizes to Promote an Art Forgery Forum in Australia
Serial Forger Sentenced but Hundred of Bogus Paintings Still in Circulation

Most Popular

Viral Fashion: How the Facebook Wedding Dress Turned Priscilla Chan Into an Unlikely Style Star
The ARTINFO Bookshelf: 40 Books That Every Artist Should Own, Part II
K8 Hardy Ripped Fashion a New One at Her Riotous Whitney Biennial Runway Show
"When You Interrupt Us, You Have to Deal With Us": Murray Moss Invites You to Intrude at His Midtown Lab
Reagan's Blood, Bieber's Hair, Ally McBeal's PJs: 10 Freakish Items From PFCAuctions's Current Online Sale
The ARTINFO Bookshelf: 40 Books That Every Artist Should Own, Part I
Are We in an Anish Kapoor Bubble? Two Barbara Gladstone Shows Point to the Affirmative

Popular on Social Media

  • "I Don't Like the Term Installation": Daniel Buren on His Grand Palais-Filling Monumenta Show
  • Is Antony Gormley Plotting His Own Foundation in Norfolk?
  • Garage Sale at 11 West 53rd Street! MoMA Curator Sabine Breitwieser on Crowdsourcing Junk for Martha Rosler
  • What If Your Prized Painting Turns Out to Be Nazi Loot? The Niche Market for Art Title Insurance
  • Sale of the Week, May 27-June 2: Christie's Week-Long Hong Kong Auctions Cater to Every Taste
  • Allen Jones, Table (detail), 1969
    Allen Jones's Soft Porn Sculptures Spice Up Sotheby's Gunter Sachs Evening Sale, but Warhol Dominates
  • "When You Interrupt Us, You Have to Deal With Us": Murray Moss Invites You to Intrude at His Midtown Lab
  • K8 Hardy Ripped Fashion a New One at Her Riotous Whitney Biennial Runway Show
  • Viral Fashion: How the Facebook Wedding Dress Turned Priscilla Chan Into an Unlikely Style Star
  • Bonhams Australia Present Six Auctions of Amazing Art and Antiques from May 27 to 29

GO TO:

Home page

Editorial

  • Visual Arts
  • Performing Arts
  • Architecture & Design
  • Artists
  • ART PRICES
  • Market News
  • Style & Society
  • Events
  • Travel
  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Slideshows

Products

  • Magazines
  • Gallery Guide
  • Blouin Art Sales Index
  • Somogy
  • Art Sites
  • Art Jobs

Louise Blouin Media

  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Louise Blouin Foundation
  • RSS
Copyright © 2012 All rights reserved. Use of the site constitutes agreement with our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.